Thinking Out Loud - Ms. Green

Commentaries from a female, conservative Christian worldview. Intermittent observations on human behavior and current events. Occasional bursts of personal tirades,confessions, and discoveries. Frequent discussions about my "Narrow-Minded Faith".

<< Back to Main Page

Wednesday, December 20, 2006

Male or Female? Athlete Fails Gender Test

Shanti Sounderajan won the silver medal in the women’s 800 metres at the Asian Games only to be disqualified for failing the gender test. The WHAT? The gender test. Naïve as it may sound, it hadn’t occurred to me that anyone would even so much as think it necessary to gender test someone. Not being much of a sports fan, I’m ignorant on this particular subject.

The Indian Olympic Association has asked the Athletic Federation of India to return the medal.

I found out that gender tests are done by a medical evaluation panel that generally includes a gynecololgist, an endocrinologist, physchologist and internal medicine specialist.

Soudnerajan appeared to have more “Y” chromosomes than allowed.

Gender testing was evidently first implemented at the 1966 European Track and Field Championships, where they required women athletes to walk nude or almost nude before judges. Over the years, the gender testing evolved to physical examinations and then chromosome tests. But how accurate even are these tests?

Here is an interesting interactive study of Gender Testing of Female Athletes

This also begs the question. Is there really such a thing as a sex-change operation? I’ve always been skeptical. I think the better term would be sex-mutilation or sex-alteration operation. All the cutting and pasting of tissue you want won’t change the bottom line of who you are.


Continue reading..


At 11:19 PM, Blogger Robert Bayn said...

I heard about this case, this person looks like a woman for the most part, but in some cases i believe some Males have more female genes, and vice versa, the only way to be sure would be to disclose all medical information, and if a 'sex change' took place, strip the athlete of the Medal.

At 2:08 PM, Blogger brooke said...

I'm thinking that the sex change thing is what they're worried about.

You only get a Y chromosome one way...

At 2:09 PM, Blogger brooke said...

Oh, and sex alteration WOULD be more accurate; DNA will still say what sex you started out as.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home